A lot of things hapÂpened for workÂing peoÂple this year, and most of them were bad. But even in a year as deranged as 2020, the broadÂer themes that afflict and enerÂgize the labor moveÂment have carÂried on. If you are readÂing this, conÂgratÂuÂlaÂtions: There is still time for you to do someÂthing about all of these things. Here is a brief look at the Year in Labor, and may we nevÂer have to live through someÂthing like it again.
The panÂdemÂic
BroadÂly speakÂing, there have been two very large labor stoÂries this year. The first is, ?“I have been forced into unemÂployÂment due to the panÂdemÂic, and I am scared.” And the secÂond is, ?“I have been forced to conÂtinÂue workÂing durÂing the panÂdemÂic, and I am scared.” America’s labor reporters spent most of our year writÂing variÂaÂtions of these stoÂries, in each comÂpaÂny and in each indusÂtry and in each city. Those stoÂries conÂtinÂue to this day.
The fedÂerÂal govÂernÂment left workÂing peoÂple utterÂly forÂsakÂen. They did not creÂate a nationÂal wage replaceÂment sysÂtem to pay peoÂple to stay home, as many EuroÂpean nations did. OSHA was asleep on the job, uninÂterÂestÂed in workÂplace safeÂty relatÂed to coroÂnÂavirus. RepubÂliÂcans in ConÂgress were more intent on getÂting liaÂbilÂiÂty proÂtecÂtions for employÂers than on doing anyÂthing, anyÂthing at all, that might help desÂperÂate regÂuÂlar peoÂple. And, of course, Trump and his allies unnecÂesÂsarÂiÂly politiÂcized pubÂlic health, leadÂing directÂly to hunÂdreds of thouÂsands of unnecÂesÂsary deaths and the ecoÂnomÂic destrucÂtion that goes with that. It was a bad year. The largÂer politÂiÂcal instiÂtuÂtions creÂatÂed to proÂtect workÂers did not do their jobs. The labor moveÂment was left very much on its own. And its own track record was mixed.
Front-line workÂers
The year of the hero! We love our heroes! Our front-line workÂers, our delivÂery peoÂple and sanÂiÂtaÂtion workÂers and bus driÂvers, our paraÂmedics and nursÂes, our cooks and cleanÂers and groÂcery workÂers: We love you all! Sure, we will bang pots and pans to celÂeÂbrate regÂuÂlar workÂers who had to push through durÂing the panÂdemÂic, and we will write you nice notes and have school chilÂdren draw signs celÂeÂbratÂing you. But will you get paid for this?
How well have unions repÂreÂsentÂing these front line workÂers done this year? In many casÂes, not well. I think first of the groÂcery workÂers, repÂreÂsentÂed by UFCW, who were genÂerÂalÂly awardÂed with temÂpoÂrary ?“hazÂard pay” bonusÂes rather than actuÂal raisÂes. Or of the UFCW’s meatÂpackÂing workÂers, whose plants were encourÂaged to stay open by an execÂuÂtive order, and who sufÂferedterÂriÂbly from the coroÂnÂavirus and from management’s utter disÂdain for their welÂfare. These are workÂers who, parÂticÂuÂlarÂly durÂing the earÂly phase of the panÂdemÂic, had a ton of leverÂage. Had they struck, or walked out, askÂing for basic safeÂty and fair pay for riskÂing their lives, the pubÂlic would have neared panÂic, and their demands probÂaÂbly would have been met. Their employÂers would have had no choice. Instead, there was a great deal of outÂcry from their unions, but no real labor actions at scale. Thus, the meatÂpackÂing workÂers conÂtinÂued to sufÂfer, and the groÂcery workÂers saw their ?“hazÂard pay” bonusÂes disÂapÂpear, and here we are.
The point of this is not to be harsh. Faced with an unexÂpectÂed disÂasÂter, most unions have spent this year scramÂbling desÂperÂateÂly to keep themÂselves and their workÂers afloat, and have been floodÂed with the task of dealÂing with the catÂaÂstroÂphe that has cost milÂlions their jobs. But when this is all over, there should be a seriÂous postÂmortem about what could and should have been done betÂter. And that will include, right up top, the failÂure of front line workÂers to turn their newÂfound hero staÂtus?—?and the temÂpoÂrary, absolute necesÂsiÂty that they conÂtinÂue workÂing through life-threatÂenÂing conÂdiÂtions?—?into any lastÂing gains. It is easy to surÂrenÂder to the feelÂing of just being thankÂful to be employed while othÂers sink into poverÂty. But we need to be ready with a betÂter plan for next time. BilÂlions of dolÂlars and a good deal of potenÂtial powÂer that workÂing peoÂple could have had has evapÂoÂratÂed because unions were not preÂpared to act to take it.
PubÂlic workers
TeachÂers unions conÂcluÂsiveÂly demonÂstratÂed their valÂue this year. In genÂerÂal, in cities with strong teachÂers unions, pubÂlic schools did not reopen unless the teachÂers were satÂisÂfied that adeÂquate workÂplace safeÂty proÂceÂdures were in place. (In pracÂtice this meant that many school disÂtricts simÂply kept instrucÂtion online.) While this earned the ire of some parÂents, they should think it through: WorkÂplace safeÂty in AmerÂiÂca only existÂed where unions were strong enough to see to it that it hapÂpened. Schools were the most promiÂnent examÂple of that.
ElseÂwhere, the news for fedÂerÂal govÂernÂment employÂees was gloomy. The Trump adminÂisÂtraÂtion waged a years-long war against the labor rights of fedÂerÂal workÂers, and it is fair to say that the unions lost that war. FedÂerÂal employÂee unions in parÂticÂuÂlar, and state employÂee unions in RepubÂliÂcan states, have become pathetÂiÂcalÂly weak. Much of their barÂgainÂing powÂer has been outÂlawed by RepubÂliÂcan politiÂcians. The unions have been reduced to writÂing politeÂly angry letÂters as their workÂers are abused while waitÂing for a new DemoÂcÂraÂtÂic adminÂisÂtraÂtion that they can beg to restore their rights. It is not a workÂable modÂel for a union. These unions must decide at some point that they are willÂing to break the law in order to assert the funÂdaÂmenÂtal rights of their memÂbers, or they will grow increasÂingÂly less able to demonÂstrate to memÂbers why they have any value.
That may not be fair, but it’s the truth.
OrgaÂnizÂing
The biggest issue for unions in AmerÂiÂca?—?bigÂger than any panÂdemÂic or presÂiÂdenÂtial elecÂtion cycle?—?is that there are simÂply not enough union memÂbers. Only one in 10 workÂers is a union memÂber. In the priÂvate secÂtor, that figÂure is just over 6%. The decades-long decline of union denÂsiÂty is the underÂlyÂing thing robÂbing the once-mighty labor moveÂment (and by extenÂsion, the workÂing class itself) of powÂer. If unions in AmerÂiÂca are not growÂing every year, they are dying.
DisÂasÂtrous years like 2020 tend to put strucÂturÂal issues on the back burnÂer, but they can also serve as inspiÂraÂtions for peoÂple to join unions to proÂtect them. The annuÂal figÂures for the year are not out yet, but anecÂdoÂtalÂly, union leadÂers and orgaÂnizÂers are optiÂmistic that the pandemic’s havÂoc will serve as fuel for future orgaÂnizÂing. Most unions manÂaged to at least conÂtinÂue major orgaÂnizÂing efforts that were already underÂway this year, like SEIU’s sucÂcessÂful conÂcluÂsion of a 17-year batÂtle to unionÂize 45,000 child care providers in CalÂiÂforÂnia. IndusÂtries that were already hotbeds of orgaÂnizÂing tendÂed to remain so. The safeÂty net of a union conÂtract clearÂly demonÂstratÂed its valÂue far and wide this year, at least in the abilÂiÂty of union memÂbers to negoÂtiÂate terms for furÂloughs and sevÂerÂance and recall rights and all the othÂer things that matÂter durÂing disÂasÂters, as non-union workÂers were simÂply cast out on their own.
Still, it is up to unions themÂselves to have a conÂcertÂed plan to take advanÂtage of the wideÂspread nationÂal sufÂferÂing and chanÂnel it into new orgaÂnizÂing. Since unions have spent the year transÂfixed by the elecÂtion and by tryÂing to respond to the ecoÂnomÂic colÂlapse, it is safe to say that such a conÂcertÂed plan does not realÂly exist yet. That needs to be done, soon, or this moment will have been wasted.Â
Strikes
DurÂing the earÂly months of the panÂdemÂic, a fragÂile sort of labor peace reigned. The grip of the criÂsis was such that most workÂers were simÂply tryÂing to hang on. As time went by, and the failÂures of employÂers became more clear, that peace began to evapÂoÂrate. TeachÂers unions around the counÂtry used credÂiÂble strike threats to head off unsafe school openÂing plans. And in the healthÂcare indusÂtry, unions have had mulÂtiÂple strikes, as nursÂes and hosÂpiÂtal workÂers have passed their breakÂing points.
LeverÂage for workÂers varies wideÂly by indusÂtry right now, as cerÂtain indusÂtries are besieged with unemÂployed workÂers lookÂing for any job they can get (restauÂrants), and othÂers are desÂperÂate for skilled workÂers, who are extremeÂly vital (nursÂes). At minÂiÂmum, every union should look at its leverÂage in the speÂcifÂic conÂtext of the panÂdemÂic and ask if they should act now, lest an opporÂtuÂniÂty be lost forever.
Gig workÂers
You can think of many enorÂmous comÂpaÂnies as huge algoÂrithms that are makÂing their way through the AmerÂiÂcan labor force, turnÂing employÂees into indeÂpenÂdent conÂtracÂtors or freeÂlancers or part-timers. There is monÂey to be made in freeÂing busiÂnessÂes from the responÂsiÂbilÂiÂty and cost of proÂvidÂing for employÂees (a staÂtus that comes with benÂeÂfits and a host of workÂplace rights, includÂing the right to unionÂize). The ?“gig econÂoÂmy” is not just Uber and Lyft and Instacart and othÂer comÂpaÂnies that excluÂsiveÂly work in that space?—?it is an ecoÂnomÂic force of nature pushÂing every comÂpaÂny, includÂing yours, to get your job off its books, and to turn you into someÂthing less than a full employee.
CounÂterÂing this force is probÂaÂbly the sinÂgle most imporÂtant legal and legÂislaÂtive issue for labor as a whole, because this process inherÂentÂly acts to disÂsolve labor powÂer. UnforÂtuÂnateÂly, the most imporÂtant thing that hapÂpened on the issue this year was the pasÂsage of Prop 22 in CalÂiÂforÂnia, legÂisÂlaÂtion specifÂiÂcalÂly designed to empowÂer the gig econÂoÂmy comÂpaÂnies to the detriÂment of workÂers. ScariÂer yet is the fact that the sucÂcessÂful legÂisÂlaÂtion in CalÂiÂforÂnia will now be used as a blueÂprint for state legÂisÂlaÂtion around the counÂtry. ComÂpaÂnies are preÂpared to spend hunÂdreds of milÂlions or bilÂlions of dolÂlars on this issue, because they save far more monÂey on the back end and preÂserve their busiÂness modÂel, which depends in large part in extractÂing wealth that once went to workÂers and rediÂrectÂing it towards investors. Either AmerÂiÂca will have a nationÂal reckÂonÂing with what the gig econÂoÂmy is doing to us, or we will conÂtinÂue barÂrelÂing towards a dystopiÂan future of the Uber-izaÂtion of every last indusÂtry. IncludÂing yours. If ever there were a good time to launch a workÂer coop, it is now.
The elecÂtion and Washington
After an earÂly periÂod of hope for a Bernie-led insurÂgency of the left, unions coaÂlesced around Biden. They spent a ton of monÂey on him, and indeed, his rhetoric and his platÂform are both more definÂiÂtiveÂly pro-union than any presÂiÂdent in decades. Unions expect a lot of things from Biden, and expeÂriÂence tells us that they will not get many of them.
What they will probÂaÂbly get: a much betÂter NLRB, a funcÂtionÂing OSHA, a pro-labor Labor DepartÂment rather than the oppoÂsite, and, parÂticÂuÂlarÂly for unions with longÂstandÂing ties to Biden, relÂaÂtiveÂly good access to the White House. What they probÂaÂbly won’t get: pasÂsage of the PRO Act, a very good bill that would fix many of the worst probÂlems with U.S. labor law, but which has no hope in a dividÂed ConÂgress. (And, I susÂpect, even with full DemoÂcÂraÂtÂic conÂtrol of ConÂgress, many of the more cenÂtrist DemocÂrats would sudÂdenÂly find a reaÂson to oppose the act if the ChamÂber of ComÂmerce ever thought it might actuÂalÂly pass). It is true that the cenÂter of the DemoÂcÂraÂtÂic ParÂty is slowÂly movÂing left, but Biden is a man who natÂuÂralÂly stays in the midÂdle of everyÂone, and he will be conÂserÂvÂaÂtive in his willÂingÂness to burn politÂiÂcal capÂiÂtal by pushÂing pro-labor poliÂcies that don’t enjoy some amount of pubÂlic biparÂtiÂsan supÂport. The politÂiÂcal cliÂmate for unions will be simÂiÂlar to what it was under ObaÂma. The words will be nicer, but any action will have to be proÂpelled by peoÂple in the streets.
The nine-month odyssey between the pasÂsage of the CARES Act and the next relief bill that ConÂgress actuÂalÂly passed is a useÂful demonÂstraÂtion of the limÂits of labor’s lobÂbyÂing powÂer. While parÂticÂuÂlar unions, espeÂcialÂly those in transÂportaÂtion and the USPS, showed skill at getÂting conÂcrete mateÂrÂiÂal gains for their memÂbers into bills, the inabilÂiÂty to force any sort of timeÂly action from ConÂgress in the face of masÂsive human sufÂferÂing shows that labor as a speÂcial interÂest will nevÂer have the politÂiÂcal powÂer it craves. Until many, many more AmerÂiÂcans are union memÂbers, it will be imposÂsiÂble to break out of this trap.
The labor moveÂment at its highÂest levÂel must break itself of the addicÂtion to the false belief that salÂvaÂtion will be found if only our DemoÂcÂrat can win the next elecÂtion. It won’t. OrgaÂnize milÂlions of new workÂers and teach them to always be ready to strike. The DemoÂcÂraÂtÂic ParÂty must be dragged towards progress by an army, and our army is weak. The AFL-CIO got burned in the protests this year. It remains to be seen if it learned anyÂthing from that.
EndÂing on a posÂiÂtive note
It may be the perÂpetÂuÂal nature of unions that the leadÂerÂship is often disÂapÂpointÂing, but the grassÂroots are always inspirÂing. The big picÂture for orgaÂnized labor in 2020 has been… close to okay, in some aspects, but cerÂtainÂly not great. But when you pull out a magÂniÂfyÂing glass and look at what indiÂvidÂual workÂers and workÂplaces and units are doing, you will find thouÂsands and thouÂsands of inspirÂing things. And not even a panÂdemÂic has changed the basic fact that orgaÂnizÂing is the most powÂerÂful tool that regÂuÂlar peoÂple have at their disÂposÂal in a sysÂtem that valÂues capÂiÂtal over humanity.
If you are an employÂee, you can unionÂize your workÂplace. If you are a gig or temÂpoÂrary workÂer, you can orgaÂnize with your coworkÂers. If you are unemÂployed, you can march in the streets now, and unionÂize your next job. All the labor moveÂment is is all of us.
This blog originally appeared at In These Times on December 23, 2020. Reprinted with permission.
About the Author: Hamilton Nolan is a labor reporter for In These Times. He has spent the past decade writÂing about labor and polÂiÂtics for GawkÂer, SplinÂter, The Guardian, and elseÂwhere.Â