The Senate Finance Committee’s health care reform proposal released this morning falls far short of the comprehensive reform that would provide working families with the quality and affordable health they desperately need, say health care advocates.
In a statement this morning, outgoing AFL-CIO President John Sweeney says the bill
“fails to meet the most basic health care needs of working families and it fails to meet the expectations we have set for our nation.”
The labor leaders say the Finance Committee bill’s reliance on so-called health care co-ops as an alternative to a public option
fails to put pressure on private insurers to control health care costs. There is no history or logic behind the claim that health care co-ops would provide real competition for the giant private insurers that have a stranglehold on health coverage today.
While the bill’s main author, committee chairman Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.), spent weeks trying to win some moderate Republican backing for the plan, not a single GOP senator has endorsed it. One key Finance Committee Democrat has already announced he will oppose the Baucus bill unless significant changes are made.
Along with dropping the public health insurance option-which is part of the House bill (H.R. 3200) and the Senate Health, Education Labor and Pension (HELP) committee bill-the Baucus bill also taxes some health plans and individuals who fail to buy private insurance, while providing no penalties to irresponsible employers who do not provide coverage.
While taxing group plans that may have higher costs because the plans cover older workers, workers with worse than average health histories or who simply live in higher cost areas, it imposes no taxes high cost individual plans.
Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.), a long-time advocate of health care reform, says because the bill abandons the public health insurance option-among other objections–
there is no way in present form I will vote for it. Therefore, I will not vote for it unless it changes during the amendment process by vast amounts… I am putting down a marker, which I think others should put down, too, who might feel the same way I do.
There are, some provisions in the bill that do provide important insurance industry reforms and improvements in how health care is delivered and paid for with a focus on quality over quantity. But say the AFL-CIO leaders
But the proposal’s strong points are nowhere near sufficient to outweigh its problems. However well intentioned the attempts at bipartisanship, the final product reflects the bankrupt policies of the past more than the forward-looking policies needed to drive meaningful health care reform.
We are counting on finance committee Democrats to fix the bill and side with working families, not insurance companies.
The Finance Committee is scheduled to begin mark-up of the bill-when improving amendments can added-next week. The Senate HELP committee has approved its version and action on the House legislation is expected later this month.
About the Author: Mike Hall is a former West Virginia newspaper reporter, staff writer for the United Mine Workers Journal and managing editor of the Seafarers Log. He came to the AFL-CIO in 1989 and has written for several federation publications, focusing on legislation and politics, especially grassroots mobilization and workplace safety. He carried union cards from the Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers, American Flint Glass Workers and Teamsters for jobs in a chemical plant, a mining equipment manufacturing plant and a warehouse. He’s also worked as roadie for a small-time country-rock band, sold blood plasma, and played an occasional game of poker to help pay the rent. You may have seen him at one of several hundred Grateful Dead shows. He was the one with longhair and the tie-dye. Still has the shirts, lost the hair.
This article was originally published in AFL-CIO blog on September 16, 2009. Re-printed with permission from the author.
making a product with hoodia Hoodia Sure Rapid Gels import and export of hoodia
Hoodia gordina hoodia gordini 423. Greentea And Hoodia cortisol hoodia
hoodia and heart problems Ephedra And Hoodia hoodia slimming pills
hoodia gordoni Irwin Naturals Hoodia oprah show hoodia
hoodia hypertension Hoodia Gordonii And Toxicity Oprah winfrey and hoodia oprah winfrey hoodia 364.
google hoodia Hoodia Drops weight loss hoodia cbs november!
“hoodia gordonii bbb” Hv Hoodia hoodia gnc
hoodia 24 Hoodia Species hoodia gordonii plus sellers
does hoodia dex-l10 work Ma Huang And Hoodia Combination hoodia chaser
100 pure hoodia gordonii Hoodia Xt 10-day hoodia diet
hoodia gordonii energy Ephedra Hoodia hoodia for diet
bulk hoodia? 100 Pure Hoodia Gordonii hoodia pro and cons
hoodia and diet Hoodia Gordonii South African hoodia medicinal
power pops with hoodia Hoodia Mist lowest price on hoodia hoodia
perfect hoodia! Hoodia 90 Diet Aide slimquick hoodia;
hoodia afordable Hoodia Slim hoodia glucomann blend
hoodia balance Body Choice Hoodia hoodia safety
hoodia gordonii cactus plant Hoodia Talk hoodia xpf,
hoodia weight loss product Hoodia Opinions hoodia walgreens
hoodia gordonii purist Hoodia Gordonii And Discount Purchase 100 hoodia patch
what is hoodia x57! Who Sells The Real Hoodia google hoodia
high fiber hoodia Hoodia Glucomann Blend “hoodia gordonii weight loss claims”
buy hoodia wholesale; Hoodia Bantning hoodia stories;
phentermine 37.5 overnight phentramine hoodia Natural Health Hoodia pure health hoodia
fat pill hoodia? Hoodia Diet Max “hoodia patch retailers”
pure hoodia tincture; Is Hoodia Safe consumer reports hoodia
clinical study hoodia Competitively Priced Hoodia hoodia liquid extract
Hoodia weight treatment hoodia weight watchers 663. Hoodia Gordonii Plus organic hoodia
slimciti hoodia 90s Ephredrine Hoodia hoodia slim,
oprah winfry and hoodia Hoodia Birthcontrol hoodia research
Hoodia cheap hoodia chews discount 404. Does Hoodia Really Work hoodia chews discount?
hoodia diet sit Zoft Hoodia Gum hoodia dex l10
walmart hoodia Hoodia Cleanse “mega t with hoodia”
nv south african hoodia Ephedra Hoodia Fusion hoodia real plant
lowest price on hoodia hoodia Hoodia Pro natural weight loss appetite hoodia!
dex-l10 hoodia Hoodia Fusion Drink “hoodia gordonii blood presure”
diet pills with hoodia Us Grown Hoodia hoodia species
hoodia herb Hoodia Whole Foods Market making a product with hoodia
import and export of hoodia Hoodia Cellulite Hoodia gordina hoodia gordini 423.
cortisol hoodia Hoodia Weight Loss Product hoodia and heart problems
hoodia slimming pills Hoodia Ratings hoodia gordoni
oprah show hoodia How Much Hoodia Is Safe hoodia hypertension
Oprah winfrey and hoodia oprah winfrey hoodia 364. Hoodia Aerial Parts google hoodia