As the AFL-CIO struggles with a growing debate over its alignment with police unions, the disagreement inside of the labor coalition itself is becoming more pointed. At an internal meeting of the Executive Council on Friday, AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka spoke out against the idea of kicking police unions out of the coalitionâ€”confusingly, by comparing them to the employers that unions bargain against.
In an exchange with a union president who spoke out forcefully against the historic role of police as foes of labor, Trumka defended the police as â€ścommunity friendly,â€ť and argued that if unions could learn to work with employers to handle contentious issues, they should be able to do the same with cops and their unions.
Since the beginning of the ongoing nationwide protests against police violence, there has been a heated discussion about what role police unions should play in the labor movement. Many progressives want to sever ties with police unions altogether, while othersâ€”particularly public-sector union leaders, who fear that any attacks on police unions will translate into attacks on all collective bargaining in the public sectorâ€”counsel moderation and â€śengagementâ€ť with police unions to push various reforms.
The AFL-CIO, a coalition of 55 unions representing 12.5 million members, has found itself in the center of the controversy. On June 8â€”a week after the AFL-CIOâ€™s Washington headquarters was burnedduring a protestâ€”the Writers Guild of America, East, an AFL-CIO member union, passed a formal resolution calling on the AFL-CIO to disaffiliate from the International Union of Police Associations, the coalitionâ€™s police union member. (I am one of the 21 WGAE council members who voted on the resolution).
The leadership of the AFL-CIO received the resolution unenthusiastically. They immediately put out a statement saying that they â€śtake a different view when it comes to the call for the AFL-CIO to cut ties with IUPA. â€¦We believe the best way to use our influence on the issue of police brutality is to engage our police affiliates rather than isolate them.â€ť Secretary-Treasurer Liz Shuler, Trumkaâ€™s second-in-command, advocated instead developing â€ścodes of excellenceâ€ť to encourage police unions to change from within.
But the issue has not disappeared. Union locals and progressive factions within larger unions have taken up the call. The King County Labor Council expelled the Seattle police union last week, and even SEIU leader Mary Kay Henry, the head of the most powerful union outside of the AFL-CIO, said that disaffiliation â€śmust be consideredâ€ť if police unions donâ€™t reform. Last Friday, the proposal from the Writers Guild received its first serious and direct discussion at a meeting of the AFL-CIOâ€™s executive council, the elected body that governs the group.
According to a source who was on that call who asked to remain anonymous due to the sensitivity of internal deliberations, Mark Dimondstein, the head of the American Postal Workers Union, raised the issue, saying that the AFL-CIO would eventually have no choice but to deal with the issue head on. Citing the WGAEâ€™s resolution, Dimondstein said that the AFL-CIO needed to grapple with â€śirreconcilable differencesâ€ť between police unions and other union members, because the role of police is to protect corporate power, not the power of working people. He called for Trumka to distribute the resolution to the Executive Council for further discussion at a future meeting, and then voiced his own opinion that any police who beat union members could not be his â€śbrother or sister.â€ť
In response, Trumka, who was leading the meeting, pushed back against some of Dimondsteinâ€™s points. Trumka, a former leader of the United Mine Workers, said that he had seen anti-worker police violence in the mining industry, but argued that many police officers today are â€ścommunity friendly.â€ť He also disagreed with Dimondsteinâ€™s characterization of laborâ€™s differences with police as â€śirreconcilable.â€ť
â€śIâ€™d just point out that we have irreconcilable differences with every employer we deal with, yet we deal with them,â€ť Trumka said. He told Dimondstein that in the same way that unions use collective bargaining to deal with employers, so, too, could organized labor use the process to â€śnarrowâ€ť differences with police unions.
The disagreement shows that the dispute over the AFL-CIOâ€™s affiliation with police is not going away, and that an internal battle may be looming. Also noteworthy is Trumkaâ€™s somewhat baffling comparison of police unions to employers, as an argument against disaffiliationâ€”an argument that would seem to imply that police unions are an opponent to be bargained against.
Employers, of course, are not part of the AFL-CIO.
This blog originally appeared at In These Times on June 22, 2020. Reprinted with permission.
About the Author: Hamilton Nolan is a labor reporter for In These Times. He has spent the past decade writing about labor and politics for Gawker, Splinter, The Guardian, and elsewhere. You can reach him at Hamilton@InTheseTimes.com.
One thought on “AFL-CIO Leader Richard Trumka Defends Police Unions by Comparing Them to Employers”
Police Unions: What’s Next for Labor?
On Tuesday, September 1, 1:00PM (Eastern) we will be hosting a YouTube Live discussion on the subject of Police Unions: What’s Next for Labor? with esteemed organizer and journalist Hamilton Nolan, who has written for Gawker, Splinter, The Guardian, CJR, among others.
In our conversation entitled Police Unions: What’s Next for Labor? we will delve into these topics and more:
What should we know about police unions and their affiliation with the AFL-CIO?
Should others follow Writers Guild of America, East, which unanimously passed a resolution calling on the AFL-CIO to disaffiliate with the International Union of Police Associations?
What can labor leaders do to support Black workers and organizers pushing for change without denying police officersâ€™ their collective bargaining rights?
As many of you saw in our Understanding Police Unions webinar, the UnionBase team remains committed to supporting labor leaders and workers who want to take part in dismantling the racist system of oppression resulting in the needless deaths of Black people in the United States.