Here are a few Short Takes worth sharing:
Ninth Circuit Certifies Wal-Mart Class Action: InÂ Dukes v. Wal-Mart, a decision from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on April 26th, the Court certified a class in a Title VII lawsuit involving 1.5 million women seeking compensation for back pay. The Court remanded the case to the district court for a determination regarding punitive damages based upon several factors set forth in the decision. The next step is most likely a request for the Supreme Court to hear the case. For more about the case, see the California Punitive Damages Blog. For an interesting story about Betty Dukes, the Wal-Mart greeter and lead plaintiffÂ see the article here from the Huffington Post. This case is reported to be the largest class action in history.
EEOC Collects $471,000 In Sex Harassment Case: The EEOC reported last week that Everdry Marketing and Management paid $471,096 in damages, plus $86,581 in post-judgment interest to 13 victims of sexual harassment. The payout stems from a four week jury trial in Rochester, New York and a Second Circuit Court of Appeals decision which affirmed the award in favor of the plaintiffs. The case involved a prolonged period of physical and verbal sexual harassment of mostly teenage telemarketers by male managers and co-workers at Everdryâ€™s Rochester, N.Y. location including demands for sex, groping, sexual jokes and constant comments about the bodies of women employees.Â The story presents another example of the widespread problem of teenage sexual harassment in the U.S
Has The Sixth Circuit Had An Attitude Adjustment?
Two cases last month out of the Sixth CircuitÂ Court of Appeals made me think that attitudes on employment discrimination cases may be shifting.
Summary Judgment Reversed In Race Discrimination Case: In Thompson v UHHSS Richmond Heights Hospital, Inc, the plaintiff was terminated from her position as a food production supervisor when she was told that her position was eliminated in a restructuring. Thompson believedÂ that she was selected for termination because of her race and filed a lawsuit. The district court granted summary judgment against her. The Sixth Circuit reversed finding that evidence of Thompsonâ€™s superior qualifications in comparison to the employee who assumed most of her job duties showed that she was replaced and also showed pretext. In addition, evidence that a supervisor said to â€śget rid ofâ€ť certain black employees whom he called â€śtroublemakers,” which the district court gave â€ślittle weight,” corroborated accusations of discriminatory behavior according to the Court.
Sexual Harassment Verdict Affirmed On Appeal: In West v. Tyson Foods,Inc. the Court affirmed a sexual harassment award including $750,000 for past and future mental distress, and $300,000 in punitive damages. In addition to great language on damages, the Court also addressed the sufficiency of reporting sexual harassment to one supervisor as constituting â€śnoticeâ€ť and a â€śmissing evidenceâ€ť jury instruction from which the jury is entitled to draw a negative inference. The plaintiff, an assembly line worker, was subjected to a barrage of verbal and physical harassment â€“ 10 to 15 times per shift — during her five weeks of employment at the Tyson Foods plant in Robards, Kentucky. The jury awarded more in damages that West’s lawyer requested which the Sixth Circuit both addressed and confirmed.
*This post originally appeared in Employee Rights Post on May 12, 2010. Reprinted with permission.
About the Author: Ellen Simon: is recognized as one of the leadingÂ employment and civil rights lawyers in the United States.She offers legal advice to individuals on employment rights, age/gender/race and disability discrimination, retaliation and sexual harassment. With a unique grasp of the issues, Ellenâ€™s a sought-after legal analyst who discusses high-profile civil cases, employment discrimination and womanâ€™s issues. Her blog, Employee Rights Post has dedicated readers who turn to Ellen for her advice and opinion. For more information go to www.ellensimon.net.